Another Option for a Nucleic Acid COVID-19 Vaccine: DNA Vaccines: Hidden and Forgotten Methods for Delivery: Lost in the Mix

Nov 16, 2020, 07:00 ET, it was announced that INOVIO received approval from the U.S. Food & Drug Administration (FDA) to proceed with Phase 2 of its Phase 2/3 clinical trial for INO-4800, its COVID-19 vaccine candidate. INO-4800 is the only nucleic-acid based vaccine that is stable at room temperature for more than a year and does not need to be frozen in transport, an important factor for implementing mass immunizations. INOVIO’s DNA vaccine plasmid is delivered directly into cells intramuscularly or intradermally using INOVIO’s proprietary hand-held device called CELLECTRA®. The CELLECTRA device uses a brief electrical pulse to reversibly open small pores in cells to allow the plasmids to enter, overcoming a key limitation of other DNA vaccines and mRNA vaccines. Once inside cells, the DNA plasmids enable the cell to produce the targeted antigen. The antigen triggers the normal T cell and antibody-mediated immune responses. The CELLECTRA device ensures that the DNA plasmids are efficiently delivered directly into the body’s cells to drive the immune response. INOVIO’s DNA vaccine does not interfere with or change in any way an individual’s own DNA. The advantages of INOVIO’s DNA vaccine platform are how fast it was designed and manufactured; its stability, not requiring freezing for storage and transport; and the robust immune response, safety profile, and tolerability evident in clinical trials. The CELLECTRA® electroporation device developed by Inovio Pharmaceuticals, Inc., is currently being assessed in clinical studies for both prophylactic and therapeutic applications.

This device delivers square-wave electric pulses by applying an adaptive electric field based on constant current, rather than constant voltage. This system measures electrical parameters and adjusts appropriately for changes in tissue resistance in realtime to avoid tissue damage and diminished DNA cell entry. The device has been evaluated in animal models, including mice, pigs, and rhesus macaques, and demonstrated acceptable immune responses.

DNA vaccines have been criticized in the past because of the possible off-target effects in expression of protein, integration of foreign DNA into the host genome and difficulties in delivery to the right target cells. As noted above INOVIO has provided evidence that they have overcome these limitations by plasmid design and a proprietary electroporation device. The concern about plasmid in comparison to mRNA vaccines is that they must enter the nucleus to be converted into mRNA before being translated into protein in the ribosomes of the cytoplasm. mRNA vaccines do not require entry into the nucleus before this last step. I have spent a lot of time providing accounts and data of the Brooks Counterproliferation Team’s work on these problems for different military applications in previous posts. It is ironic that INOVIO has received a significant level of funding from the Department of Defense independent of our work: On June 23, 2020, INOVIO received a $71 million contract from the U.S. Department of Defense to scale up its manufacture of its CELLECTRA® 3PSP Smart Device and procurement of CELLECTRA® 2000 for COVID-19 DNA Vaccine delivery https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3906411/pdf/hvi-9-2246.pdf.

Alex Careaga @alexcareaga
The starting material, 3-amino-L-tyrosine (3AT) is an amino acid analogue of L-DOPA, the latter which can be converted into melanin. The 3AT, through substitution and elimination, yields the following
polymer (trivial name: diazoluminomelanin: DALM).

Our work began with efforts to synthesize a microwave and radio frequency electromagnetic radiation interacting polymer starting in 1981. We succeeded (1 March 1988) in making one from the amino acid 3-amino-L-tyrosine which through diazotization ended up with the following structure:

This polymer demonstrates a number of interesting and very applicable physical and chemical properties. It is thermochemiluminescent while oxidizing, binds to DNA without damaging it functionally, and further interacts instantly with pulsed direct current electric fields, and those of pulsed radio frequency and microwave radiation. The classical explanation of its behavior is as an inductor, that it is a passive two-terminal electrical component that stores energy in a magnetic field when electric current flows through it. An inductor consists of an insulated wire wound into a coil around a core. When the current flowing through an inductor changes, the time-varying magnetic field induces an electromotive force (e.m.f.) (voltage) in the conductor, described by Faraday’s law of induction. According to Lenz’s law, the induced voltage has a polarity (direction) which opposes the change in current that created it. As a result, inductors oppose any changes in current through them. The coiled ground state structure of DALM may be responsible for its behaving as a molecular inductor. The discharge of luminescence and/or thermalization are related to the release and conversion of this stored energy.

The build up of energy into dark states leading to high E fields may facilitate electroporation. During electroporation, the lipid molecules simply shift position, opening up a pore which acts as a water- filled conduction pathway through the bilayer. Electroporation is a dynamic phenomenon which depends on the local transmembrane voltage at each point on the cell membrane. For a given pulse duration and shape, a specific transmembrane voltage threshold exists for the electroporation phenomenon (from 0.5 V to 1 V) to occur, an electric field magnitude threshold for electroporation.
Ribbon-like structure of DALM with sharp edges and angular high aspect ratio ends unlike amorphous globular natural melanin
The conversion to sound allows for the possibility of transporting DNA into cells by sonoporation. Sonoporation has already demonstrated potential utility in gene transfer https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-018-22056-8.pdf.

The next step was to try to make DALM from feedstock chemicals fed to bacteria that have inducible nitrate reductase. When this process was not totally satisfactory, genetic modification with plasmids delivered by electroporation or calcium phosphate was tried and succeeded in enhancing the production of DALM. This even worked with mammalian and human cells harboring nitric oxide producing enzymes (nitric oxide synthase, NOS) which could integrate with a component of the barley plant nitrate reductase to enhance both their activities simultaneously.

Nitrite production by electroporatically transfected cells measured by Griess Reagent absorption of 546 nm visible light.
Human HeLa (top) cells (HeLa NR1 ATCC ® CRL-13011™ Homo sapiens cervix adenocarcino: https://www.atcc.org/Products/All/CRL-13011.aspx) and E. coli bacteria producing nanoparticles (white particles) after transfection and transformation, respectively, with the appropriate plasmid vectors of barley nitrate reductase components and fed feedstock for DALM biosynthesis.
Plasmid used in HeLa cells (HeLaNR1) to make them biosynthsize DALM and DALM nanoparticles. The presence of SV40 genes allows for integration into the host genome and what has made ATCC concerned about licensing the cell line’s use and that it be handled in a BSL-2—because of the potential of transfer of “infectious” viral oncogenic material.

Thermochemiluminescence of oxidizing biosynthetic DALM made by transfected HeLaNR1 cells compared to controls.
The plasmid used in E. Coli to produce DALM nanoparticle DNA transformation vectors.
Schematics of nucleic acid (plasmids and mRNA) coating and transfer by biosynthetic DALM.
Overall design of scheme of making and delivering DALM nanoparticle vectors of expressible DNA as for vaccines.
HeLa P6 cells showing fluorescence tracking of transfecting nanoparticles to nucleus
Showing tracing fluorescent Nanobes (DALM nanoparticles) carrying transfecting DNA and resulting PCR demonstrating presence of vectored DNA in human kidney cells (HK2). These results show that DALM vectors do not require an electric field to be taken up into human cells.
Freeze-dried DALM nanoparticle vectors which were still functional after 4+ years storage at room temperature and ambient light in the lab.
These commercially available nanosprayers could facilitate the transdermal transfer of DALM nanoparticle vectors for clinical use as for DNA plasmid vaccination; similar devices could be used for inoculation by inhalation.

Plasmids transferred to target cells with DALM nanoparticle vectors have demonstrated desired functional transfer such as antibiotic resistance for clonal selection, antimicrobial activity, and DALM nanoparticle biosynthetic capability, but also the less desirable transfer and off target effects of genome integration in mammalian and human cells (expected based on plasmid constructs used), and in bacteria, not only the clonal selection antibiotic resistance, but also the off target effects of bacteriophage resistance and hemolytic activity in a pathogen (Bacillus anthracis, anthrax). The DALM nanoparticle vector has demonstrated its broad utility as a potential plasmid DNA vaccine vector and also its ability to be manufactured by microbes’ making biosynthetic complete DALM, nanoparticle, plasmid DNA vectors for genetic transfer.

Leave a comment